Search
/Menu

2245 Bee Ridge Rd Sarasota, Florida 34239 | Restaurant Info

Menu
Info
Reviews

You have items in your basket that are not currently available for delivery at this time.
Please remove the red highlighted items in your basket to proceed.

Main Menu

Hours: 11:00 AM to 4:00 PMAvailable at 11:00am.

This item is locked!

This item is not available for the delivery time you have selected.

To add this item to your cart for a future order, please schedule the order delivery time to be between 11:00 AM to 4:00 PM.

Popular

Photos

Main Menu

Tarts & PiesToggle visibility of menu section "Tarts & Pies"

$16.00

Classic Key Lime Pie

Our Award Winning Key Lime pie. Try this amazing treat in a graham cracker crust topped with a whipped topping border. It's the right combination of tart, sweet, and tangy. This is a favorite of all who try it.

$16.00

Chocolate Swirled Key Lime Pie

Our Chocolate Swirl Key Lime is a delicious combination of tart key lime and rich dark chocolate. This is our classic key lime pie swirled with dark chocolate into the top. This is a must try.

$17.00

Tropical Fruit Key Lime

Try a Key Lime pie that doesn't follow the norm. The Tropical Fruit pie has raspberry, mango, and guava puree swirled into the top of a Key Lime filling in a graham cracker crust. Finished with whipped topping.

$17.00

Mango Key Lime

How about a Mango Key Lime pie for dessert? Our traditional Key Lime pie swirled with mango in a graham cracker crust for an extra burst of flavor. Finished with whipped topping.

$17.00

Raspberry Key Lime Pie

A tasty variation of our award winning Key Lime Pie is swirled with a rich raspberry melba sauce and topped with a whipped topping border. This provides a little different taste but the key lime flavor still is dominant. A beautiful presentation for a...

$16.00

Banana Cream/Salted Caramel

This Banana Cream with Salted Caramel is just as mouth watering as its name. You will know exactly what we mean once you get your first bite of Sea Salt, Caramel and Banana all infused together. Yumi!

$16.00

Coconut Cream

Our Coconut Cream pie is unlike anything you have ever tasted. It's a creamy intense coconut with shredded coconut and topped with toasted coconut in a graham cracker crust.

$17.00

Chocolate Silk Pie

This is a two layer chocolate pie in an Oreo crust. It has a bottom layer of chocolate ganache on the bottom and then topped with a light and fluffy chocolate mousse and shaved chocolate covering the top of the pie. Topped off with whipped cream. If you...

$17.00

Orange Dreamsicle

An old time taste that may bring back memories. The Orange Creamsicle is reminiscent of the ice cream/popsicle combination of yesteryear. The tart orange taste is perfectly balanced with a creamy smooth taste and whipped topping.

$17.00

Peanut Butter

We all love peanut butter so why not take a chance with this rich, creamy Peanut Butter pie topped with chopped peanuts in a graham cracker crust. One of our newest pies with great reviews. Yum!

$17.00

Tart Taster

A Tart Taster is a great way to enjoy many of our delicious varieties. Each sampler has one Key Lime, Chocolate Silk, Banana Cream/Salted Caramel, Tropical Key Lime, and Coconut tart included. You can decide which is your favorite and follow with a whole pie!

$7.00

Mini Dessert or Hor D'Oeuvre Tarts

A perfect addition for your next dinner party or event. Tiny shortbread or phyllo bite size tarts can be filled with key lime or any key lime variation, coconut, chocolate silk, or peanut butter with a minimum of one dozen per variety. Only phyllo tarts can...

$5.00

Key Lime Pie on a Stick

Enjoy your favorite Key Lime Pie topped with chocolate. Our original award winning Key Lime Pie is dipped in Belgian chocolate for a double treat. Sensational. Minimum of 6 for shipping.

FudgeToggle visibility of menu section "Fudge"

$7.00

Fudge

Our homemade Fudge is made with real cream and butter. Available in a variety of flavors (Chocolate, key lime, peanut butter, vanilla, tiger butter, chocolate nut) cut to order or in prepacked state of Florida or rectangular packages. Call for more...

Menu pricing is controlled directly by Caribbean Pie Company.

Menu SelectionsToggle visibility of Menu Selections

Main Menu

Tarts & Pies Fudge

Your Order

Caribbean Pie Company

Item	Qty	Price	Del
No items added yet!

Pickup

Delivery

Date

Time

Time selected is time of delivery.

Checkout

About Caribbean Pie Company

https://caribbeanpieco.com

Delivery Area

Delivery Hours

Monday:	11:00 am to 4:00 pm
Tuesday:	11:00 am to 4:00 pm
Wednesday:	11:00 am to 4:00 pm
Thursday:	11:00 am to 1:30 pm
Friday:	11:00 am to 1:30 pm
Saturday:	10:00 am to 2:30 pm
Sunday:	Closed

Ordering Info

Min Order:	From $0 for delivery No minimum for pickup
Contact:	(941) 882-4589
Serving:	Bakery Desserts

Booking fees & order minimums vary by your distance from the restaurant.

The order minimum for delivery has not been met!

Your order subtotal must meet the delivery minimum to place this order for delivery.

Yes, show prices No, don't show prices

Please select a menu type.

Items in the basket are not available for the time selected.

Remove the red highlighted items in your basket or select a different time to proceed.

Bite Squad

This item is locked!

Your Order

Caribbean Pie Company